The function of unbiased specialists within the Artwork Market

France has a number of belongings although, remembers thierry Ehrmann, CEO and Founding father of and its Artprice division, “and notably its hidden inventory of outdated masterpieces, a variety of which often discover their manner into the nation’s public sale rooms yearly. Nevertheless it takes all of the know-how of an professional in Previous Masters to defend their worth and their rightful place in Artwork Historical past. The standard of the work performed by French artwork specialists is at the moment recognised everywhere in the world.”

The professional lives at 69… rue Sainte-Anne in Paris

Previous Grasp work professional Eric Turquin admits that the sale of the small devotional panel attributed to the Grasp of Vyssi Brod was in all probability his agency’s greatest success story in 2019. And but the yr was full of pleasure because the Cupboard Turquin was deeply concerned within the sale of the Toulouse Caravaggio in June 2019 (which lastly bought privately), the Cimabue portray in October and even a piece by Artemisia Gentileschi in November.

Nonetheless, the attribution of that small panel to the artist often known as Grasp of Vyssi Brod, a 14th century Gothic painter from Prague, was certainly a veritable tour de power. It took a variety of affected person analysis to again up this delicate attribution, however it in the end demonstrated the distinctive worth of this small portray. 9 bidders competed for it in Dijon and it lastly went to the Benappi Tremendous Artwork Gallery that purchased the work for $6.Eight million on behalf of the Metropolitan Museum of Artwork in New York. 

An intense analysis file was additionally triggered by the invention of a bronze bust of Paul Phélypeaux de Pontchartrain, certainly one of Henri IV’s Ministers. When auctioneer Géraldine d’Ouince noticed it for the primary time, she exclaimed “It will possibly’t be 17th century… it will be too good to be true… no extra exist! …” . Busts from that interval are certainly extraordinarily uncommon, even in probably the most prestigious museums, and they’re completely absent from the market. However, with the assistance of Elodie Jeannest and Alexandre Lacroix of the Sculpture & Assortment appraisal agency (additionally primarily based at 69 rue Sainte-Anne in Paris, subsequent to the Cupboard Turquin), they have been capable of set up that the bronze dated from the primary half of the 17th century.

All in all, Géraldine d’Ouince acknowledged earlier than the general public sale that the estimate supplied within the catalogue – between $550,000 and $885,000 – might be considerably exceeded, and certainly the bust of Paul Phélypeaux fetched nearly $3.Four million.

The French mannequin

Whereas it represents a distinct segment market in the USA producing simply 3% of the American artwork market’s whole public sale turnover, the Previous Masters section accounts for as a lot as 14% of the nice artwork public sale income in France. Final yr, this section benefited from the wonderful work of the nation’s consulting corporations, usually involving prolonged analysis that’s completely obligatory earlier than an public sale home can hope to draw knowledgeable and satisfied consumers.

When an appraisal report is each convincing and conclusive, information of the sale appears to unfold nearly by itself. The media and the Artwork Market are keen on tales of forgotten or misattributed artwork works that steadily recuperate their rightful locations in artwork historical past because the analysis advances and the proof accumulates. In the long run, the technical analyses, x-rays and comparisons with different masterpieces are introduced in a gross sales catalogue… and the work’s true identification and historical past are revealed.

The wonderful outcomes hammered in France throughout 2019 have proved that when an appraisal report has been duly established, the sale of the piece could be held exterior the key capitals – in locations like Toulouse, Dijon and even within the small city of Senlis – and nonetheless appeal to the world’s greatest collectors and museums.

High 10 Previous Masters at public sale in France in 2019

1. CIMABUE (c. 1240/50-c. 1302) – Christ Mocked
$26,780,000  (Estimated: $4,400,000$6,600,000)
27/10/2019, Hôtel des Ventes de Senlis

2. Grasp of Vyssi BROD (act.1350-) – The Virgin and Little one on the Throne
$6,833,000 (Estimated: $440,000$660,000)
30/11/2019, Cortot & Associés, Dijon

3. Artemisia GENTILESCHI (1593-c.1654) – Lucrèce
$5,255,000  (Estimated: $660,000$880,000)
13/11/2019, Artcurial, Paris

4. Antonio SUSINI (Attrib.) (1558-1624) – Abduction of a Sabine (c.1590-1610)
$4,985,000 (Estimated:  $2,775,000$5,545,000)
11/12/2019, Sotheby’s, Paris

5. Giambettino CIGNAROLI (Attrib.) (1706-1770) – Portrait of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart […]
$4,435,000 (Estimated: $880,000$1,320,000)
27/11/2019, Christie’s, Paris

6 Ambrosius I BOSSCHAERT (1573-1621) – Lower flowers in a Römer […] 
$3,709,000 (Estimated: $2,470,000$2,800,000)
06/19/2019, Fraysse – Binoche & Giquello, Paris

7. Francesco BORDONI (1580-1654) – Paul Phélypeaux […]
$3,372,000 (Estimated:  $550,000$885,000)
20/11/2019, from Baecque – d’Ouince, Paris

8. Hans DAUHER (c.1485-1538) – Putti (c.1525-1530)
$2,630,000  (Estimated: $1,120,000$1,680,000)
16/05/2019, Sotheby’s, Paris

9. Bernardino LUINI (c.1480 / 85-1532)2,534,000 – Madonna and Little one with Saint George
$2,534,000 (Estimated: $1,980,000$ 2,200,000)
14/11/2019, Aguttes, Paris

10. Antonio SUSINI (Attrib.) (1558-1624)  La fortune (1580-1600)
$2,011,000 (Estimated: $1,110,000$2,220,000)
12/11/2019 Sotheby’s, Paris

Promote or appraise: you need to select

An appraisal carries a lot extra weight when carried out by an unbiased agency whose repute is at stake relating to the objectivity of its report.

An auctioneer who sees a piece for the primary time is already partly dedicated to its sale and the standard of his/her work might be measured in response to the success of the transaction. Public sale homes typically give the impression of over-focusing on the advertising and monetary features of a sale. When Patrick Drahi acquired Sotheby’s and appointed businessman Charles F. Steward to its head, it despatched out a robust sign about Sotheby’s technique and priorities. Within the case of Salvator Mundi, one could marvel if Christie’s did not put extra vitality into organizing its worldwide tour than analyzing its creative qualities and questioning its place in da Vinci’s œuvre.

In the interim, each Eric Turquin and Alexandre Lacroix appear to understand their collaborations with French public sale homes, whether or not Parisian or provincial. There isn’t a doubt these auctioneers profit from its experience, data, expertise and repute however, above all from its independence. This avoids sure pressures from the Artwork Market, during which conflicts of curiosity typically have repercussions… even within the collections of the biggest museums.

A pledge of high quality

Greater than twenty years in the past, Thomas Hoving – former Director of the Metropolitan Museum of Artwork – already drew the artwork world’s consideration to the presence of fakes in massive museum collections. In 1997, he wrote within the introduction to his e book False Impression, The Hunt for Massive-Instances Artwork Fakes: “Within the decade and a half I spent on the Metropolitan Museum of Artwork, I needed to study fifty thousand works in all areas. In whole, 40 % have been fakes, or had been restored so hypocritically or so poorly attributed that they have been precisely the identical as fakes. Since then, I’m positive that proportion has elevated. […]

When artwork grew to become an more and more costly commodity within the 1970s and 1980s, fakes flourished. The younger millionaires or billionaires started to covet artwork as an object of funding, in addition to a mark of status and social superiority. Because the originals have been now not quite a few sufficient, the false Previous Masters (or absolutely repainted) stuffed the gaps.”

The previous MET Director lent credence, a minimum of partly, to this clarification: “One of many fiercest of all [fakebusters], the Italian Giuseppe “Pico” Cellini, now in his early eighties and nonetheless exposing all types of creative rubbish, believes the tendency of most American museums to maintain their fakes quiet or secret is because of their having bought out to their rich donors and trustees. Maybe he would not exaggerate.

It’s in all probability no coincidence that in 2019 the Metropolitan Museum of Artwork in New York was one of many main consumers of work appraised by Eric Turquin’s unbiased agency. The French experience faces a brand new world demand.

Picture: [  ] 

Copyright 1987-2020 thierry Ehrmann

Strive our providers (free demo):

Subscribe to our providers:

About Artmarket: is listed on Eurolist by Euronext Paris, SRD lengthy solely and Euroclear: 7478 – Bloomberg: PRC – Reuters: ARTF.

Uncover Artmarket and its Artprice division on video:

Artmarket and its Artprice division was based in 1997 by its CEO, thierry Ehrmann. Artmarket and its Artprice division is managed by Groupe Serveur, created in 1987.

See licensed biography in Who’s who ©:

Artmarket is a worldwide participant within the Artwork Market with, amongst different constructions, its Artprice division, world chief within the accumulation, administration and exploitation of historic and present artwork market info in databanks containing over 30 million indices and public sale outcomes, masking greater than 740,000 artists.

Artprice Pictures® permits limitless entry to the biggest Artwork Market picture financial institution on the planet: a minimum of 180 million digital photos of pictures or engraved reproductions of artworks from 1700 to the current day, commented by our artwork historians.

Artmarket with its Artprice division accumulates knowledge on a everlasting foundation from 6300 Public sale Homes and produces key Artwork Market info for the primary press and media businesses (7,200 publications). Its 4.5 million ‘members log in’ customers have entry to advertisements posted by different members, a community that at the moment represents the main International Standardized Market® to purchase and promote artworks at a set or bid value (auctions regulated by paragraphs 2 and three of Article L 321.Three of France’s Industrial Code).

Artmarket with its Artprice division, has been awarded the State label “Modern Firm” by the Public Funding Financial institution (BPI) (for the second time in November 2018 for a brand new interval of three years) which is supporting the corporate in its undertaking to consolidate its place as a worldwide participant out there artwork.

Artprice by Artmarket’s 2019 International Artwork Market Report printed in February 2020 :

Index of press releases posted by Artmarket with its Artprice division:

Observe all of the Artwork Market information in actual time with Artmarket and its Artprice division on Fb and Twitter: (4.9 million followers)

Uncover the alchemy and universe of Artmarket and its artprice division headquartered on the well-known Organe Up to date Artwork Museum “The Abode of Chaos” (dixit The New York Instances):

L’Obs – The Museum of the Future:

(4.5 million followers)

Photograph –  
Brand –

Contact and its Artprice division –

Thierry Ehrmann,


You may also like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *